Excellent story idea
Awesome ship level design
Very challenging
Awesome traps (The floor collapsing scared the crap out of me)
The oilrig map changes itself every so often (fences and such are added)

The swimming/water part of the engine room level is very confusing, For those confused...Move your ass or you will run out of oxygen.

The finale seems very unfinished and wide open, No medkit or weapon stashes outside of the saferoom that I could find aswell.

I played this with one other friend on advanced and I probably won't play again unless I get four actual players as the bots get really confusing in this campaign.

All in all if you are looking for a simple way to kill an hour, then I recommend this campaign.

Brilliant detail
Great setting
Love the HL2 barrels

A few places where the bots found it difficult to get to (ladders on 1st (i think) level.
Maybe add a few arrows or signs to improve navigation

One of my favorite addon campaigns and one of my favorite campaigns in general! Just a few things to sort out to make it perfect!

Great maps
Fun Finale

Few bugs to work out. Got caught in a continuous horde attack for the last half of map 3 for example.

Overall a great campaign. My favorite thus far.

Really nice detail and atmosphere.

Pretty long, yet the levels didn't seem repetitive.

Awesome, big ass explosion in that room with all the barrels.

Pretty nice finale.

On the third or second level, there were a bit to many crescendo events.

It's a little confusing to get around at first, but I got the hang of it pretty quickly.

Overall, I really liked this campaign. Surely, it's one of the best campaigns out there. Just like Sir Bubbles said, It almost felt like an official campaign.

Awnsom !!! Wonderfull !! Giant !!!!!
What a crazy moment i just spend !
I was really scare, really lost! this is hard but it is just perfect !!!!!!!!!!!!
You can give a second life to your left for dead 1 game!
And in versus, what a crazy holly shit moment !!!

This man do this on his own ... Without any help!

Congratulation for spending so much time to offer us this campaign!!! Thank you very much

Great design and detail
Challenging
Exploding barrels

Quite short
Many problems with zombie and bots navigation: hordes occasionally couldn't get to us and the bots often stayed in place until the game decided to teleport them. Also, stupid bots don't know how to stay away from the electrified fence.

If you like your daily close quarter claustrophobic zombie slayage you'll definitely love this map. I couldn't find any ammo on the finale area, which can be quite a problem, but I didn't put it as a con since it might just have been me being blind.

everything worked perfect great campaign

none

best campaign i ever played keep up the good work, now this needs to be for l4d2

Excellent levels design-logical
Creativity-I LOVE the idea of tanker ship and oil rig!
Good graphic-impressive even when camparing with valve's works.
Atmospheric-ways after ways of infected swarm toward survivors as they try to make it to the finale saferoom.

4 maps only.

Very well done.

Really well designed, Valve quality!
Didn't encounter any bugs, nice optimizing!
Alternate path/crescendo in map 3 was a excellent feature!

Could use some more ammo placements.
The booby traps on map 2 were a nice touch but bots had difficulty with them.
Needs a bit more hints at where to go at times.

Overall a great campaign, the design really is top notch and it didn't have any buys! The alternate path/crescendo feature was a pleasant surprise and the finale worked very well, although I was a bit disappointed with the fact that the huge tower was left out. Maybe it's a good idea to give the players the impression that the helicopter is going to land at the heliport but after the second tank, you get a message from the pilot that he can't land there for some reason and that he's going to pick you up at the top of the tower. Just a thought.

Lastly some maps could use a bit more ammo placements as you seem to run out of ammo rather quickly. Some of the booby traps on map 2 were a nice touch but lot's of times the bots had difficulty navigating around them so they would often teleport beside you, even when boomed. Also especially on the later maps, a few hints on where to go would be nice.

great design
nice traps
new structures like the tall tower at the finale

finale area seems too cut off and I find it funny that you have a tall tower that you can't uses during the finale battle. At least I couldn't at the time.

Very Fun Map

Nice series of maps
Exciting for everything to be at sea
A perfect challenge for me

Maps are sometimes difficult to navigate - although this is not fully a bad thing as come the Zombie apocalypse we are unlikely to have helpful arrows showing us where the safe rooms are.
I would have liked more information about what happened to the oil rig workers. i.e. more interesting grafitti in the safe rooms.

A great map - thanks for creating this for us.

+ one huge ship!
+ challenges
+ under water is cool
+ Literally Left 4 Dead sometimes
+ I shot witch and Zoey got thrown off 2 floors! It was epic!

- Hard to navigate sometimes
- Easy to get lost at the beginning
- Beginning, no back up!?
- Easy to get lost
- Bot gets stuck at high tower at finale
- No way to get back up at the end
- Last fall in 2nd map = pointless
- Tank knocks off a survivor towards the top, survivor is alive for 1/2 a min.
- 10 continuous horde spawns in one of the last maps

Pretty darn good for a beta, but needs some work still of course.

You are literally left 4 dead on the ship almost half the time, including the finale! Kinda annoyed me how you could not get back up at the finale.

Finale: Tank sound comes on.... no tank? Really? He dies real quick like too like he was on fire and got stuck. A scare tactic? Interesting. Also, can't get back up to where other survivors with rifles are.. usually... wtf...??

There's a place in 2nd map at the end... a drop that's really pointless. The zombies & special infected are gone by then. There's really no point. There's also a spot where we were climbing up the stairs. I shot witch, and I ran for it. I later found out teammates gunned her down, but the witch (as an act of desperation) knocked Zoey down about 2 stories... I was laughing my @$$ OFF!! HAHA! There's another spot towards the top before the electric walls. Thank showed up... Knocked survivor off into the water... He was alive for like a minute miraculously and game had to spoil it.. next 30 seconds and he was dead... either have him dead when he falls or keep him alive.. that was a dirty glitch mister... =-p Also, one of my teammates there had to shoot Zoey (who was still at the sniper point) and get her incapacitated for the heli to fly away... wtf...?

Lastly, there was a spot in map 3 where we had to activate a switch.. only 2 of us there... like 10 hordes in a row we had to fight through to rescue b4 we could get the other survivors... wtf...??

Excellent story idea
Awesome ship level design
Very challenging
Awesome traps (The floor collapsing scared the crap out of me)
The oilrig map changes itself every so often (fences and such are added)

The swimming/water part of the engine room level is very confusing, For those confused...Move your ass or you will run out of oxygen.

The finale seems very unfinished and wide open, No medkit or weapon stashes outside of the saferoom that I could find aswell.

I played this with one other friend on advanced and I probably won't play again unless I get four actual players as the bots get really confusing in this campaign.

All in all if you are looking for a simple way to kill an hour, then I recommend this campaign.

Very nice visuals, it all flows nicely
Hard to get lost
Good item spawns

Cresendo events are a bit overdone
Finale battlefield seems too small
Finale and cresendo have spots that make it easy to hold out

Overall, this is a great campaign. It really does feel like a boat/oil rig, and it has a nice length.
Although the cresendo events you picked are tried and true (Use generator to open door, use forklift to make bridge)
They tend to get boring. Maybe throw something new at the players.
I liked the explosive barrels too. That one room around the end was a killer.
I was disappointed that you cant fight on that giant tower, you can only grab supplies from it. Incorporating it into that finale could have made it so much better.
This campaign is a must play, with your friends.

Well scripted, not too hard. Great design!

End map a little confusing

All in all a great map! I do agree with some people that there needs to be a ladder or something allowing you to use the large tower during the finale. Throw an ammo pile and a few pipe bombs and med kits up there to! I can imagine having two people up there sniping while the others run around. THAT would be cool!

Fun
Easy
Multiple paths to take

Minor frame rate problems throughout the campaign but really Bad frame rate on level 3 and 4
Ammo is too far away from radio and sort of hidden on finale. The guns are also missing from the finale.
Level 1 was too easy
On level 2 the tank got stuck and never came to fight.
On level 3 there's a crate toward the top that says danger on it. If you touch the crate next to it you get hurt and continue to get hurt until you die.

Aside the frame rate issues, I can see it becoming popular within the community. Can't wait to play the final product.

very detailed
new location
a lot to see
pretty realistic

a little bit to short
somtimes confusing

look below

- Nice maps
- Interesting Design
- No Bugs
- Rescue Finale nice
- Simulate very real

- some models not appear
- some points in camp , bots don't know away to go

No ideas , No matters , Utouchable . This is Perfect Campaign.

+ Very, very detailed levels.

+ Good Crescendo Events.

+ Great atmosphere on the finale.

+ The tank smashed Zoey and Francis on the finale with one rock and I got a very good laugh out of it.

- The 2nd tank on the finale bugged out and camped on top of the tower, throwing rocks at us, he still did his job but it was an easy takedown.

- There were a LOT of Boomers, which made it quite frustrating some times.

Overall this is a very great campaign, possibly the best custom campaign I have ever played. It has an official campaign level of quality. I highly recommend it to everyone.

Lot of créatives idea, good ambiance, and logic construction.

The picture of bush!

Lot of good idea, very exiting in versus mode ! Good thinking.

nice layout
good lighting
good events

no spawn points if you die(got killed by tank at beginning of map2, had to wait till end safe room to rejoin)

very good campaign

Excellent scenario!
Great confined areas.
Scenery!

Slight confusion as to switch activation sequence

Being a former US Navy squid, this map brings great memories back into my head. The watertight doors and other nautical parts of this map are a nice change from the usual L4D maps. I'll enjoy playing this one for a long time. Thank you!

Nice length.
Great design.
Balanced difficulty.

We got a bit lost now and then and ended up going in circles, so perhaps a few more arrows would make it a bit clearer.

Overall, it was a great campaign and we enjoyed it ^^

Looks magnificent
Great design
Very original
Neat ideas
Well executed
Fun finale

The 1st and 3rd levels can be very confusing
You can go of the elevator and get stuck with no way to get back up

This is a beta? When I played this it felt like it was 101% complete! This map is very good. I have very little complaints, and besides the complaints I do have, this map is perfect. The 1st and 3rd levels are confusing, but fix the elevator, and this map will be just a little more enjoyable.

- Not too short, not too long.
- Not too hard, not too easy either :)
- Fast paced
- Didn't come across any glitches or things that didn't work.

There are too many weapons around - perhaps you could reduce the number to make it more interesting.

Very nice campaign! I loved it.

Well done and keep up the good work :)