Everything

none

Great campaign, really great! We successfully finished it in expert, 0 restarts.

If you want, you can watch it at youtube: /watch?v=MJO2rNc1l2M

Thanks a lot! We enjoyed it so much!

Good length, quick campaigns are boring.
Great detail, everything looks pretty realistic for a game.
Graffiti (Did I really see a Spaced reference in there?)
Finale, I've found a lot of custom campaigns suck at the finale stage, but this one was really good.

Playing with bots is annoying, especially at the train bit.
Some MINOR glitches, Hunters jumping through walls once or twice, but nothing major.

This campaign really feels like something Valve's done, it fits with the game and storyline very well and I would suggest anybody who likes L4D get this immediately!

the football field was great! starting in an aparment. and that train ride

too bad the commen infected were in football gear

the campaign was the greatest map i have ever played.

Everything

none

Great campaign, really great! We successfully finished it in expert, 0 restarts.

If you want, you can watch it at youtube: /watch?v=MJO2rNc1l2M

Thanks a lot! We enjoyed it so much!

-The biggest of this campaing: AWESOME DETAILED STORY and GREAT ATMOSPHERE!
-The Elevator part was great, exspecially the Hunter ^^. The idea with the restoring power rocks, too.
-many new sound clips for storyline
-some new notes for the events etc
-a recolored alarm car :D
-The train part is awesome ^^ The radio, the idea, the trainride, everything

-I missed the classic "Start in an open area without saferoom door" ont he campaign start ^^'
-The campaign itself is quite easy... the only difficult part of it is the mass of tanks. Actually i just played advanced and got 2 every level and additional 2 witches nearly every level. Just to much tanks o.o
-Bots are kinda stupid when it comes to the train part ^^' Lost 2 due to jumping off the train.
-I missed the explosives on the finale. Just found 2 cans of oil, not enough!

Great campaign with a new, well shown story, good atmoshere, some nice new ideas.
The only real con is the annoying amount of tanks.

I would give it a 95 in total ^^ I don't mind getting 2 Tanks/Level on Expert... But there shouldn't be more then 1 if it isn't expert.

-VERY detailed
-Terrific level design

-The stadium finale is kinda cramped

This is Valve's missing campaign no doubt!

- Greatly (is that a word?) made.
- Feels like one of Valve's official campaigns.
- Loved all those places I've been trough, mostly the train part and the stadium (finale).

- The train part is a bit laggy.
- It didn't really feel so exciting, nothing special.

Overall great map. I recommend it, it's a must play.
Had a lot of fun with it :)

Amazing map!
Perfectly balanced, infected spawns.
Nice and challenging!
Very alternating.

Easily to say... NONE!

This map is a must try for everyone interested in downloadable campaigns! It's easily the best i played out of all the custom maps. A lot of variety from prison-cells to theater, from skycrapers to footballfields. While playing this you would really forget it's fan-made and you'd think it belongs to the original storyline. That's what me and my friend thaught! ;)

great made map
no horde after horde
not easy nor hard to find the way just perfect xD

hmm to be honest cant think of one xD

this is the Must Play map of custom made maps xD

Excellent campaign. It flows well and is definitely enjoyable.

The coding is a little iffy, meaning it doesn't work right in L4D2. I would love to see something made for it as well. Also, the finale feels a little easy. Toss in some more cars for the Tank to lob around and make things a little less comfortable.

An awesome campaign that is still a joy to play, even in the days of Left 4 Dead 2.

* Nice atmosphere
* Nice setting
* Nice level-design
* Nice layout
* Nice gameplay
* Nicely detailed

* Not much, maybe a lack of originality
* Last time I played it, the finale was really crappy, too easy!

One of the best custom campaigns on Left 4 Dead 1 so far. It really blends with the other campaigns and has this creepy feeling that most of No Mercy has.

Great Maps, challenging, but not impossible
Brilliant design
AI works well

Some maps seem a little too long (in my opinion)

Overall an excellent campaign, the best custom one i've seen by far!

the levels of this map make it seem really realistic

i love how there was like, a point in the game that was related to a finale.

the finale was really cool! who would've thought of a stadium???

the name was epic :D

the chopper ending is too frequently used...

i sometimes found that the placements of the spec. infected made the game way too dificult... everytime a try a map for the 1st time, just to see how it is, i play on easy. and i still died -_-

very good map. a little too dificult... i wouldnt dare try this on expert

~Fun
~A good Length
~Classic
~Ammo/health were well separated
~The ending was a nice classic l4d ending with a fantastic battle ground.
~Hunter on the elevator (LOL)
~The bots were actually doing ok.
~Navs were good and I did not find any missing textures or any holes in the whole campaign.
~ THE TARDIS!!! (does that mean The Doctor was infected?)

Could not find anything but the bots would not always stay on the train but I don't care about them anyway. lol

I don't normally give out 100's but this deserve it. Completely playable and awesome to play through. Me and my friends posted our walk through it to. PLZ make more maps cause you rock and this! Hope the L4D2 version turns out to be as good as this one!

BTW, This has ranked my fav L4D1 Custom!

Custom models
Great fun
The tardis
The graffiti

Bots can ruin things at points

One of the best maps on L4DMaps.com

The highest technical level of the campaign allows her to compete for this indicator with Valve. Very high quality work.

In Suicide Blitz no interesting gameplay, memorable moments. I have not seen in this campaign is nothing spectacular.This is a usual campaign, despite at a high technical level.

I went through this campaign 1 time. I do not see any reason to do it yet. But it is really quality work.85.

Different, enjoyed it a lot.
TRAINS.
The crecendos are pretty different and really fun.
TRAINS.
The ULTIMATE co-op map, as well great for versus.
LOOK TRAIN.

Not enough trains.

Classic. I will play this very often :)

DId you get valve to help you on this?

This map has some of the best detail I have ever seen in custom maps.

I loled at the pacman machine. to bad you cant play it.

Your own crecendo events make it seem as if its a officaly map.

None.

As said in pros, It might as well have been made by valve it self. I love the police station click it or ticked posters.

nice campaign, loved all the stuff you have to do to advance plus all the helpful hints you get, the lighting was perfect and in all the right places

a lot of stationary zombies 15-20 to a room in almost every room seemed a little much

Good job, good campaign, will play it again

-Large Environment
-Lots of details
-Appropriate amount of items
-Fairly easy to navigate

-Lots of dead ends
-Some spots are really hard to defend while waiting for an event.

I just played this map with some friends and it was enjoyable. I played an earlier version, and I remember that on the 4th map when you are on the train, you used to not be able to get off once the event started, now you can fall off, and if you do you are literally Left for Dead.

I feel that there should be 2 large flat train cars for this event, because it is too easy for a smoker to grab you off or a boomer to explode you off. I know it was too easy before not being able to fall off the train, but you really need a little more space to be able to defend successfully. We had 3 people fall of and only 1 survived.

A lot of locations to see and explore
Excellent work in clutter placement
Original events and game objects
Good voice acting
Fun finale
4 survival maps

Bots going mad before the train event (see below)
The mounted minigun on the finale sometimes uses a wrong vertical position on the first person view (if activated when below it)
Survival map 2 acted weird (see below)

When you play this map you can see that a lot of effort has been made in creating it. A lot of locations that do not sum up to anonymous building and alleys, but rather a movie theater, a police station, and more.

For some reason some bots, in the room where you have to wait for everyone to get on the train to activate the radio, keep trying to get up the ladder that's used to get there, making it impossible to start the event since it's impossible to go back that way.
On another note, survival map 2 (the prison block in the police station) acted very weird: up to the 10 minutes mark the hordes kept spawning from the same 2 spots, leaving huge intervals of calm between them, up to 30 seconds. From 10 to 14 they used more spawn points, but still with long pauses. From 14 to 17 all hell finally broke loose. Past that I can't tell 'cause I was swimming in a pool of blood. It was kinda boring :/

tl;dr: awesome map. Must have.

Good length, quick campaigns are boring.
Great detail, everything looks pretty realistic for a game.
Graffiti (Did I really see a Spaced reference in there?)
Finale, I've found a lot of custom campaigns suck at the finale stage, but this one was really good.

Playing with bots is annoying, especially at the train bit.
Some MINOR glitches, Hunters jumping through walls once or twice, but nothing major.

This campaign really feels like something Valve's done, it fits with the game and storyline very well and I would suggest anybody who likes L4D get this immediately!

Great level design filled with unique locations and detail packed environments

AI seemed to function great

Well conceived and well executed finale

Plenty of common infected and area specific special events

Plenty of places to hole up in should higher difficulties require it.

Appeared to have good difficulty

I honestly don't have a single thing to complain about.

I feel that when someone releases a map that rivals even the work of the team at valve, it deserves an automatic 100. This map is something else.

-fun levels to play
-The campaign is really fun especially the trainstation safe house
-The finally is really fun. I really like where put the finally. I don't think valve would of thought of a finally like that one.
-Good place to put the special infected. i really like it a lot because there is on every 1 minute its just like survivor training.

-Some maps are a bit laggy like when there is a big horde attack.
-it felt like valve could've made it next time make it feel more like that valve wouldn't make.

This campaign is really fun to play. I would recommend it to anyone who loves to play left 4 dead

+ Elevator Part = Unique
+ Length
+ Footballs at stadium = priceless
+ Epic moments
+ Train at end of 4th map

- Tank = beginning of last level
- Finale's not much
- Stadium was okay

It had its moments for sure, the moment when you can get clobbered at the beginning of the last map by a tank is funny, but a fail. He should not be able to spawn there...

The length and detail was very good. I didn't see a reason for the extra space to go out the side of that one building though.. I think it was the 3rd or 4th level. The train scene at the end of the 4th map was cool, but would have been more fun if it were longer...

-Great level design

-finale was epic

-better than some of the valve campaigns

-second half very pretty looking

-Could have introduced some different gameplay elements

-the environments in the first half of the game were kind of bland and I've seen things like that in the official campaigns.

A very well made campaign I'd like to see another campaign from you. Anyone who hasn't downloaded this campaign download it now. I had a very good experience playing this campaign.

+ Well made map feels like one made by valve
+ No Bot Problems
+ Loved the hunter climbing the window in the elevator lol
+ Excellent Large Finale

- Bots sometimes fall of the train in the end of map 4.

This is one of the best maps i have played No bugs No AI Bot problems except for sometimes they fall of the train at the end of map 4 but overall this is a very good map i can't believe how good it is lol valve quality 100. Recommended for anyone who wants a challenge and a excellent campaign.

Great detail
amazingly well made
very fun to play
beats official campaigns
good placements and spawns
great campaign map
Loved it

For the first time ever in one of our reviews, NONE!

Loved it to bits amazingly well done map its spectacular beats no mercy hands down.

Youtube
Video review: watch?v=BzihPTN8tF8

Hope this servs all l4d players and the creator cos this is an epic map ^^

Very long.
It's actually better than the Valve campaigns.
The chopper pilot and the guy on the radio. Nice voice acting! Seemed as if it was put into the game.
No glitches in L4D1.

In L4D2, you can jump on top of the elevators.
There is a nav problem in the 4th map. Right before you drop down to the train area, the bots get stuck and won't do anything.

The first and probably the best campaign I've played. Loved the detail. Just make a L4D2 version and it'll be perfect. =D

Wow

And wow :)

Perfect! :) But I'm just curious, why didn't you put that the players can go to the stadium, that would be awesome. Still very good!

Great design
Very original
Neat locations
Lengthy
Many humorous signs

Slight problems with the navigation mesh on the 4th and 2nd levels

This is a very, very, very good Left 4 Dead campaign and is probably the best one yet. The stadium is an awesome location and riding the train is a very memorable moment. This campaign is just, wonderful.