- Excellent attention to detail
- Great gameplay (including the Car. Scared the crap out of me the first time!)
- Awesome finale with plenty of options that's just difficult enough to keep the players on their toes.
- Custom music (always a big plus!)

None visible!

A fantastic map that matches the feel of Left 4 Dead perfectly.

-Terrorific Music
-Huge maps
-Beautiful views
-Multiple ways to go
-Increased Difficult and not so easy to survive (Maybe novices could see this as a bad point but its a good map for everyone)
-Great ideas and constructions
-Everything XD

I didnt really see anything to consider bad

Great maps with great views and musics, simply wonderful

Was put together extremely well. If i didn't download this and it just popped up in my add on list, i would have assumed that i was an official map. The crescendo events were amazingly placed and the whole "story" of this map is really really extreme.

The only thing that bugged me the most ( which isn't very much at all ) Was that at the final stand, after we defeated the tank we had to run like.. all the way across the map to get to the escape vehicle. It wouldn't have bothered me much if my team and i didn't die like.. 4 times trying to get there. But again, this wont by any means stop me from playing it. =)

Its an extremely clever map, that was very well put together. The level design was awesome, it was fun to play with bots as well as friends, and it makes me want to play it some more just writing about it. The perfect balance of everything for a map. i highly suggest that anyone who comes to this site, regardless of whether or not you become a member, or are just looking for a quick download cause you're bored of the 5 original campaigns, to give this one a try. It's one that you'll play over and over again.

-Challenging maps
-Outstanding design

-Level 4 might cause motion sickness

Again, a campaign which looks like Valve made!

- Great level design
- Nice events, hordes invasions, etc.
- Variety of paths that doesn't make you
disoriented
- Good work with lights
- Very high-pacing action

- Finale is a little bit ... strange

Yup, I think it's one of the best custom campaigns ever. Pretty good.

Can you make the L4D2 version? It will be very nice, because it seems that the design will make possible
to play it in 'Left 4 Dead 2' with much more pleasure than in original 'Left 4 Dead'.

Interesting, imaginative maps
Fun Finale
Challenging
Ran flawlessly
Most novel escape vehicle ever!

Can't think of a complaint.

This was my first add-on to try largely because of it's already high score. Definately an impressive piece of work. Well-thought out, well-executed, fun to play. Can't go wrong with this one.

great campaign better then valves campaigns, reminds me codmw ship map

none so far

really great campaign really long maps and no bugs so far

Mostly good level design

Nice custom music

Nice feeling of holding out against the horde in the final stage

Some nice unexpected and unique touches

Levels did not link together in any sensible way and seemed extremely isolated from one another

Quite frankly EVIL placement of Tanks that generally always involved the death of one player with no
chance of survival

Tilting boat was essentially a nice touch but when it is continuously tilting is just annoying

In the finale was holding out for rescue for around 20 minutes and yet still none appeared, or if it did was not obvious that it had

Some crescendo events a little too easy

Each stage has a nice feel to it and they all seperately feel well made, however put together they don't hold any kind of coherency, which a proper campaign should have. This results in a fun playthrough but not a feeling of an overall jounrney as in official campaigns. The finale has an effect of feeling very much like a last stand but then the escape didn't seem to turn up, again diminishing the journey.

Great level design and multiple paths made this an amazing map to run through, plus a whole other level of detail added that made this as good as, if not better than, the valve campaigns.

Only minor glitch noticed, no finale music! -1pt

Definitely my favourite user made map to date, and will be playing this one again with other people.

-would be great for VS maps
-huge maps (pro and con)
-the ship level panic was hella tense
-navigation was clear and i did not get lost (much)

-too big for a run through coop mode
-too big to contain little details that make you go 'wow'
-not too coherent to tie in the maps

some good parts, but also some bad parts. the map was big for its own sake, and not good on flow or pacing.

Challenging campaign
Beautiful Scenery
The Car ;)
The Finale - good challenge
The tank smashing through the flaming car creating a path
Stable

one or two zombie spawns in a wall

Very fun, should be considered for inclusion in the actual game. Its just like the valve campains, only better.

Good work :)

-Great loading screen
-The riddle on the panic event is just amazing. Though many people don't seem to be able to solve it ^^' (hint: search the canal)
-A great idea: recolored alarm cars. Prevents from the casual "Oh, red car = alert".
-The backgrounds, exspecially in the dock parts are well made and perfectly fit the atmosphere.
-Another pro which i noted but can't read anymore XD
-The ship level was just great. Well designed, flawless and the angle of the ground was just something originally new ^^
-Also, the car event on the ship is just lol. You got me there XD
-Epic music themes in the last level part
-ULTIMATE RESCUE VEHICLE!

-Got a few early tanks... the 1st one just killed my team straight next to the saferoom, the 2nd one could just been killed due to a couple of molos next to his spawn positon. Really, don't spawn tanks without handing the survs molo's or T2 weapons.
-The first 2 levels were quite confusing and sometimes didn't show anything like a clear path.
-Usually my L4D doesn't crashes, but in this campaign it crasehd twice... in the same level... I'm not sure WHY but i can tell it's related to the level which is, sadly, the best level (ship) of the entire campaign.
-For some unknown reason the background music failed after the rescue vehicle arrived... Which made the situation somewhat strange (Hearing a tank without the tank music is lol)

(OMG stupid website told me to "login" though i am and now i have to rewrite my long review again... 2nd time this happens FIX IT!)
A surely good campaign, having some really innovative ideas (like my favourite, the recolored alert car IN GREEN) and the surely most awesome level ever (>ship), though the crashes somehow ruine it...

I would give it a 88 in total.

Very good campaign, nice layout, map I will play a lot

none that i can see

Enjoyed this 1, you did very well

4th map is awesome! Custom music is cool.

Vely low fps on some maps, you could optimize LOS, by using areaportals, func_lod and others. Strange final, to long, maybe to dangerous coz you can die easily when tank. Escape vehicle is LOL. How could it fly without someone. If addon is installed, all standart music on other campaigns not work. That car with alarm on 4th map looks creative but...

Well, to many cons. But it is playable.

this map was very very good.
- the lighthouse finale was an interesting idea. loved how it ended with a hot air ballon. that's a first :)
-the ship was an exiting level. though i got lost a few times, the fact that zombies didnt stop showing up was a good thing to distract me from that.
-the prison idea was good too. makes me wonder wtf they're doing at a prison lol

- one of the parts where you alert the horde was broken. it wouldnt turn on, so i had to noclip through it. also, the door leading out of the saferoom for the finale wouldn't open either. that 2nd part is really unkown if it was just a glitch or not, because i've never really done the map that far again.

i give it a 99 just because of the horde bug. though it does make a huge addition to the map, it can be done with out. by the time i got to the tank on that level i completely forgot. good map :D

The scenery is really impressive.
I like the idea of surprises (the car for example)
This map is brilliantly fun to play on expert.
A good variety of areas to camp for panic events/crescanados.
A good change over the 5 maps in design.

The odd glitch.
Sometimes there are low fps.
It seems really hard for survivors on versus with teams of equal skill.
There are tier 2 weps on first chapter.

Recomended for a challenge on expert. But the challenge gets even harder on versus. 89 given

- Very detailed
- Very playable
- Nice use of Panic and Crescendo Events
- A good path layout (allows you to explore without being too lost)
- Fast paced action

- Sometimes I fell off the maps which is... annoying >.<

Awesome map! Looks like Valve made it themselves, keep up the great work :D

Well designed maps, esp the ship was interesting - placement of containers and the nasty surprise :-) Custom music was also nice. map felt somewhat easier than the original l4d maps except perhaps larger number of specials.

The finale requires running a long way back to the rescue ship. For some it is not even clear when / if the ship has arrived. Unless the final horde is not that tough you will have a hard time making it there esp without grenades. With bots on Adv it is very difficult as they tend to fall and die

Tank placement: well yes it is in tight spots but you can master dodging the tank around columns and furniture pieces :-) BTw remember people y9ou can pull a tank off someone by meleeing it - and running like hell :-)

Recommened!

This was first custom campaign I've ever played and it was awesome, definitely one of the best

none

Epic campaign

- 宏大的场面，很有气势。
- 幽灵船地图很有创意。
- 细节到位，绝对经典。
- 太多，在此不一一赘述。

- 貌似幽灵船某处会卡在栏杆里，如果四个人都掉进去就杯具了。

传说中的官方第五幅战役，不可不玩！

Beautiful graphic and level design
immersive
Map is larger than normal
Well executed
Finale is fun and innovative-who would ever thought of a balloon esape?:)

AI get struck in finale-at the stairs.

Almost perfect, this is one of the best campign I have ever played!

Everything that is not in the Cons sections.
Kudos for the boat level, I can't even think about how you did it, must have been a nightmare to design, maintain and do the path-finding.

* Got lost and walked in circle at least 3 or 4 times and most of the time, I didn't knew if I was progressing or going backward because the streets look all the same. Fair enough though, because levels are huge.
* The event on the first map can be entirely slept through by camping in one of the corners.
* Got a Tank right after exiting the safe-room on the second map and couldn't backtrack to fight it, got killed in the safe-room.
* On several occasions, there was zombies in the rescue closets and I got kicked just after I was saved.
* Unable to fire the event on the second level, I thought I would have to noclip through the door but after wandering around for 10 minutes I found a gray block that I was able to magically teleport in the sewers. I still don't know why an electric problem in the sewers would have anything to do with the door's opening system.
* Bots are unable to correctly navigate in and out the sewers in the second level.
* Global lighting and shadows are somewhat... ugly and it just looks like you just did the absolute minimum to light the environments.
* Most secondary rooms are just big rectangular-shaped hollow rooms with nothing more than 4 walls, a ceiling and a floor. I doesn't really help with immersion.
* I had some huge frame rate issues in the first, third and fourth levels, falling as low as 15-20 FPS in areas with very few details.
* I kept getting stuck in the environment, it seems you didn't clipped the geometry to ease the navigation. It's a nightmare when you backtrack facing a tank and keep getting blocked by every little obstacle.
* Alarmed cars are not red just like the convention Valve used in both L4D1 and L4D2. I think you should have followed this convention.
* There's arrows everywhere to guide the player because the levels are build with too much realism and not enough visual clues on where to go.
* Most of the hordes seemed stuck somewhere and never managed to reach us or too few zombies at a time and where too easy to decimate.
* Why the hell is there crickets chirping on the docks?
* There's a supreme lack of ammunitions or they're located in places you're not even supposed to take a look at because I progressed through half of each levels without ammo.
* Events are uninspired and unoriginal. Is it a national sport to attach trash dumpsters to cranes? Come on, there a lot of props, at least attach a cargo container! Not to mention 3 out of 4 events are classic alarmed doors.
* Scripted events that kill you if you don't react faster than 1 or 2 seconds are just wrong. I'm talking about the falling car in the boat. Again, huge frame rate problems in there.
* The boat level is awesome, I can't even start to think how you built it. I wish it was a bit more easy to navigate into and that you didn't lure players into dead-ends using the lighting.
* The finale is visually awesome but on the gameplay side, it's a nightmare. Hordes need more than 2 or 3 minutes to climb up to the lighthouse and most of them fall during the climb, which means that there's only few zombies attacking survivors at a time when they're at the top.
* The setting is exceptional, but this is not exactly a good idea when there's Tanks everywhere. Each punch throw you a hundred meters out of the cliffs and everyone kept dying from this. In No Mercy, there was a good number of obstacles to prevent you from falling, but here, there's too much holes to punch you though. It's also almost impossible to reach the 'escape vehicle' depending on where you were fighting the finale. It should have parked at the top or in the middle of the area. Not far from everything at the very bottom where it takes more than 2 or 3 minutes too reach.

One of the most awesome campaign on Left 4 Dead but really need some serious polishing. Didn't tried the Left 4 Dead 2 version but I believe you didn't changed everything in it.

-Original music.
-No gameplay issues for the most part.
-Interesting finale.

-Finale may be a little too big; Tanks can punch the Survivors off the cliffs easily!
-Music kind of gets messed up after playing this Campaign.
-Needs traditional or custom ending music.
-I can still hear sounds when the credits roll.

The first Campaign I've downloaded for L4D.

good level design
love the music
interesting theme
decent finale

first map feels scattered
some areas need guard rails
clipping issues
more details needed inside the prison
the water is absolutely terrible

great map with a few bugs. the prison theme is perfect for a zombie uprising and the shipwreck is a nice touch. the water is really bad and is distracting. please fix and i will change review

- Graphics are wonderfull
- Great scenario
- Nice optimization
- Great ideas on the campaign
- The ship is unbelievable
- Nice events (especially in the 3th map)
- Campaign poster is beautiful
- Nice spots for infected
- Great challenge with Tanks and Witches (not too much)
- Good lights and ambient

- Finale is too difficult and not really wonderfull for myself (need to work on it again)
- There is no pilot in the rescue vehicle

A wonderfull campaign, the better i've seen until now ! Everything is perfect, from the first to the last map ! There is no bug knowed and it's playable in versus, co-op and survival ! You must download it, you will not regret it ! THIS CAMPAIGN IS A MUST HAVE ! And by the way, it's selected in the official ESL campaigns for tournament and ladders... so download it now and you'll have a lot of great moments on it !
PS : Diputs told me he's porting this campaign to L4D2.