Not a lot of navigation errors.

Not to long, not to short.

The intro video flows very badly. Try making the camera move more slowly.

Avoid using invisible walls. Instead make it obvious that "a-big-object" is blocking the way (and then use an invisible wall inside of the object).

Props being placed inside of other props, clipping.

Parts of the campaign are very flat. Try introducing more height differences.

Room, corridor, room, corridor. Try breaking the monotony by creating other kind of environments.

Rooftops. They totally destroy all balance in versus. One charger and the survivors has lost one (if not all) of their members.

Curious: why use street lamps instead of floodlights at the stadium? They look out of place.

The biggest annoyance was all the repetition of spaces. The most entertaining aspect was the travel over the roofs. The roofs didn't work in versus. In campaign they worked fine. They forced the survivors to stay cautious, and work together in order to survive.

fanile is awsome
seems to be decent as far as the over all map structure goes

low detail and texture resolutions
too many fieworks boxes and kitanas i the first 2 maps

this campaign is good but lacks detail and seems a bit rushed textures need improvement ect. an avrage map gets an avrage score

-very fun to play
-not to short and not too long
-very well made
-challenging
-great finale

None

i really think this map is awesome, and is definitely worth playing

a lot of L4D 2 items
one of the best rolling crescendos in map 2
no noticable gamebreaking bugs
no visual bugs

needed a bit more scenery variety

Well, afaik it's the only full L4D 2 polished ported campaign.
But infact it's a quite good one. It lacks a bit of variety but has some intense close combat spots.
I have yet to find a versus game. It seems that nobody takes the time to set up a versus lobby.

cool setting,
nice ideas

car alarms
hard to find turn off switch
can get repetitive

This map is ok, so I rate it a 50/100. I played in coop, not in versus.

Excellent finale. Very fun - loads of different options for defending - but none too easily defended.

Map worked well with lots of areas to explore.

Too many apartments/offices. There's only so much apartments and offices one person can take. Variety!!!!!

Way too many healthpacks, defibs, mollys, pipebombs, bile bombs, etc. Loads of fireworks and gas cans. Kinda felt like every time you came across something, it's time to chuck it because you'll find something else in the very next room.

Too many options. While alternate routes are nice - there definitely can be too many. The layout of this map leads to a lot of "circles" as you get to an area with several different options and well, you get turned around and before you know it, you're right back where you started.

Excellent finale. Loved the unique finale and the different options for defense. While the rest of the map is also good, it gets redundant with all the offices and apartments and doesn't present much of a challenge when there's so many goodies laying around. Despite that, I'd still recommend it to play and would say it definitely has re-playability.

Great L4D1 feel.
Very fun to play over and over again.
Lots of mobs coming in to keep you on the move.
Special Infected know the level very well.
4 maps.

Witches and Tanks spawn in the worse places!
Needs a bit more scenery.
Boomers seem to be useless at times.

Exellent map! Definetly worth a download or two, and is a great map to download if you really love L4D1. This map made me feel like i was playing on a L4D1 map on L4D2. Once again great work J. Sera! 95/100.

Nice use of props
Decent number of hoards and uncommons
Good campaign for versus and survival

Hardly any tanks
Tank music in finale didnt play
You can fall off the elevator on the third chapter
A bit too short
Bots/AI get lost when being attacked by Charger, Hunter etc.

A nice map and very fun to play but in the end it is too easy on Single Player as The Enemy | said and a few bugs can be fixed. 71/100 :)

-Fun/Amazing
-Great A.I
-Stadium Finale
-Weapon Spawn is nice

-Instant Death Spot by the safe room on the 2nd level
-Soccer field is too cluttered
-Jockeys spawn way to much on this map
-Mounted Machine gun spot sucks

It's fun but has some flaws fix them.

Good looking levels, no bugs
Bot AI is alright, no trouble getting through the map.
Cool finale

A bit too generous with resources (molotovs, pills, ammo, etc). I like having to be at least somewhat careful with my supplies so I don't run out.

Difficulty curve is pretty low throughout the campaign, but rises up steep once you reach the finale, at least when played with bots.

Deja-vu moment when I exited one of the saferooms because the room I entered was very similar to the room I entered after the starter saferoom from the level before.

An entertaining campaign. The campaign's Level design isn't super unique and memorable or something like that, but it's just good! Even though I wrote a long cons section in this review compared to the pros section (because I wanted to elaborate), I'm just nitpicking. I recommend this campaign to everyone!

- Nice aesthetics that look the part.
- No issues in terms of glitches or bugs.
- Some nice variety between chapters in terms of path layout.

- Each chapter is a little short, and overall seems quite easy due to the abundance of health kits and defibs, even on Expert mode.

I found myself rather impressed with this campaign. It takes some of the elements from Left 4 Dead 1 that worked well, and manages to be distinguishable in it's own right. Generally the saferooms seemed a little close to each other so the chapters seemed rather short, so there wasn't too much in the way of a challenge. Besides that it came across as a very well done map that could actually pass as an official map. Played this with some friends and we all came away rather entertained.
Overall this is a good well polished map that's well worth a look.

Multiple-ish paths
Riot Uncommon zombie seems plausible
Maps are easy to understand
Very polished, no FPS issues whatsoever
Has a really good potential as Versus

First running crescendo is waaayyy long
Too easy on Single Player
Almost no Tanks
Tank music in the finale didn't play

Really liked this. Has a lot paths and lot of holdouts in the finale. Unfortunately it's too easy on Single Player, but must be really fun to play on Versus.

- Nice level design suggestions
- 2nd map is very dangerous and funny too
- Big variety of weapons from the actual begining

- THE POSTER IS AWFUL! (I played v3 and v4)
- The design of the final map isn't good, I think
- The Arena looks awfull. It is too blocky and looks.. hm... Boring
- The idea of the finale used before and it was excellent in 'Dark Carnival" campaign, but in this one it isn't made that good

Nice campaign, but the finale looks boring. Yup, just boring. Nothing special or interesting.

map has some realistic areas

map is kinda blah and not that memorable

I would recommend to skip this one

Simple understandable navigation, plenty of rooms to search, probably the best concept for a finale I've ever seen.

Tanks and chargers throw me onto lamp posts and other game breaking areas.

A fine map fit for a top ten list... however I think the poster tag line should be "The home team plays for blood."

-Nice, not too difficult.
-Bots are functional.
-Use of dialogue throughout Campaign.
-The elevator can go back down just in case anybody gets left behind.
-The presence of Uncommon Infected (Riot Infected), a notable aversion of a common oversight.

-Auto Shotgun FAR too early in the Campaign.
-A few too many supplies. Vary it up a little!
-A little easy to get lost in the Finale.
-Survivor names for poster are out of place.

A nice Campaign. Putting a few rails on the lift when it goes up would prevent anyone from getting left behind. Otherwise, this is a nice, but ordinary Campaign.

-Fairly interesting
-exploration is rewarded
-interesting finally

- The levels feel bland after awhile
- in one of the levels the fricken hordes keep spawning like bunnies with to much free time on their paws

Its an ok campaign, but there is something about it that seems wrong about it and i don't know why exactly.

very fun map layout, well planned and nice movement through the levels. great stashes of fireworks

there could be more events overall at least 1 per level

a solid fun playing experience