*Good design and attention to detail, especially the interior areas.
*Graveyard is very well made.
*Train saferoom at end of map 4.
*Breeched saferoom was a good idea.
*Good amount of pickups and health.

*No intro sequence.
*Infected spawn right by the staring area in map 1.
*Special infected spawned behind fences in map 1 and got stuck there.
*Only 1 gun to choose from at sart of map 2.
*Bots can't open the rescue closet door near the river.
*Can get stuck behind trees just after rock tunnel.
*Had no idea where to go after the rock tunnel. Only found out that the river was shallow there when a horde ran across. You need to have something there to show it's shallow, rather than being very deep just a short distance upstream.
*Too many alarmed cars in the garage.
*Final crescendo event in map 4 had nothing happen that would summon a horde.
*Easy to miss the book button in the big office.
*With such a big finale area, it took a while to find the button to start it.
*No ammo found in the finale area. The only place I found any was after the first big door had opened, which is too late to have ammo. Place some that is accessible before the finale starts.
*Doors need doorframes added for detail.
*Quite a few places looked like copy and pastes from Valve's maps with a few minor alterations made.
*Nav needs some work for survivors. Some places they ran far ahead by themselves, running into tanks sometimes. They had trouble rescuing people from smokers sometimes. They kept running straight into witches, even through there was plenty of space to avoid it. Especially true on 1st map, where in a wide open road, the bots ran straight past the witch.
*Not clear where to go sometimes. Well lit areas ended up being dead ends and the route to take was sometimes hidden in darkness or hidden in a darkened corner. How to get past the motel was tricky to spot.

A campaign that starts out ok but gets better as it goes on. There are some issues that need looking at. Probably just needs a few tweaks here and there. After a few playthroughs the routing issues will become easier but it's a bit tricky for the player trying this campaign for the first time.

- Very good level design
- Long Campaign
- Great detail on each map
- Very good atmosphere
- Very good idea for the final

- Too many tanks
- Too many vehicles with alarm in the parking

Very good campaign overall, but it would be much better without all these tanks and these stupid bots.

- Very good level design
- Long Campaign
- Great detail on each map
- Very good atmosphere
- Very good idea for the final

- Too many tanks
- Too many vehicles with alarm in the parking

Very good campaign overall, but it would be much better without all these tanks and these stupid bots.

---- In general ----
+ Long campaign, almost too long.
+ Great level of detail in each map.
+ Finale area was set at dawn.
+ Clear and nice storyline.
+ Challenge in every single map.
+ Huge structures that offer more than one way.
+ Many Tanks and Witches included.
+ Good use of lighting, especially in map 3.
+ Acceptable intro and outro.
+ Finale was quite a nice idea and also worked.
+ Varied areas and surroundings.

---- Map 1 ----
- AI mates are unable to help if caught by Special Infected.
- AI mates are not able just to climb underneath things.

---- Map 2 ----
- Forest was too tight, no space to fight properly.

---- Map 3 ----
- The garage level was quite sick with hundreds of car alarms and stupid AI.
- Tank placed in the garage and cars...

---- Map 5 - Finale ----
- Bad AI navigation.
- Too less ammo stashs for this huge area.

---- In general ----
- AI navigation problems.
- AI mates sometimes don't heal up.
- No directions at all.

Well a very long campaign, but not only long, it's also good. The most annoying thing was the AI navigation, because they simply didn't like to heal up or even didn't like to help me if Special Infected, like a Smoker got me. They always have to jump up to the sideways instead of just climbing underneath the crashed plane.

- feels like a real left 4 dead campaign
- Storyline (canon)
- detail

none

I think this is a very well made campaign, thumbs up

* Makes a fair effort to innovate by breaking out of some of the L4D tropes, particularly at the beginning.
* Clearly designed for a challenge and delivers; feels like an atempt to create a Realism campaign without necessarily having to turn on Realism mode.

* Finding the way forward is needlessly difficult at times, especially with hordes coming after you.
* I have yet to see any hints at all... bogs things down.
* Lots of buildings and other constructs recycled from other campaigns; unoriginal, breaks immersion a tad, and can sometimes seriously confuse.

There's folks who will truly enjoy this campaign (probably folks who really enjoy Realism mode); good for them and I hope they continue to do so. Sadly, it's not for me. It seems a bit overly focused on realism, to the occasional detriment of fun and polish IMO. I'm here to fight through a zombie apocalypse and occasionally glance at the scenery, not get lost trying to find the one tiny window in twenty hotel rooms that leads to a barren back yard or get confused by buildings I've seen before that are subtly different and thus confusing to navigate. "Frustrating" != "challenging and fun" to me. Alas.

nice campaign
lots of molotovs ^^ yay fire!
had to look for items which was a challenge and thus, fun
looks like a combo of campaigns XD
seemed realistic situation wise
decent bot navigation

maybe too many throwables
lacks originality
strange finale rescue sequence
nothing really new or spectacular...

fun campaign. not really anything too amazing but certainly fun.

-Great design
-haha am I playing Blood Harvest, Death Toll, and Dark Carnival?
-Very fun
-Bridge Collasped before I could get to the other side, thats okay I was supposed to go the other way

NONE

Very fun and challenging. No glitches or nothing its perfect. They should'a sent some nukes when the bomb shelter closed haha.

-great map design
-nice environment

-in map 2 ,from hotel to sewer-1 AI has trouble to use ladder, and smoker get him/her
-In the subway station (city hall map), the wall colors -mix white and black near ceiling part
-hard to find a way after leaving sewer(too many trees block my view)
-less ammo piles

Over all it is still a good campaign. (v.8.0) This review bases on my SP experience. it is a long , but a great campaign I hope authers can improve and fix that 2 issues. Almost a perfet SP experience just like Valve did.

+ Looks Like Death Toll, Dark Carnival, Blood Harvest &' Alien Swarm.
+ Awesome Feeling.
+ Tons Of Zombies.
+ Huge Chapters.
+ Ammo Usage.
+ Scavenger Hunt Like. | Explained In Conclusion.
+ Lighting.
+ AI Support.
+ AI Nav.
+ FOV.
+ Multiple Tanks.
+ Pretty Straight Forward.
+ Challenging.
+ Decent Intro.
+ Sick Finale.

- Lacks Direction A Bit.

Ohh.. My.. GOD.!! That's all I can say when I finally beat this campaign. Definitely a recommended map, and a personal favorite. I personally think that this campaign should be added as on of Vavle's main list of campaigns because this is just amazing! As I said in the Pros, "Scavenger Hunt Like." I meant, you really need to search for your supplies because it isn't all in one spot all the time, there isn't always going to be a pile of guns, this campaign shows that you can't have everything. You need to work to get your equipment here, and if you don't take the time to look for your stuff or supplies, you will most likely die. The beginning was pretty cool — scratch that. THE WHOLE CAMPAIGN WAS COOL! :-D. What really got me was the scavenger hunt. I agree with AdamsKurzt on his observation that the campaign does have parts where it looks like other campaigns, I saw in the finale; the part where you are about to go down in that square thing. That is something in the game Alien Swarm. Thought that the finale was really cool too, you had to fight for your supplies. (; Great Campaign, Romka &; AGRESSOR