* Great atmosphere.
* High level of overall detail.
* Survivor dialogue.
* Smooth cutscenes (especially intro).
* Wide, non-linear environments.
* Custom SI models, textures & sounds.
* Custom ambient soundtracks.
* Puzzles.
* Huge maps.
* Fun and challenging gameplay.
* Very few survivor closets. Instead, more defib units.
* Weapons and items only spawn singly, not in stacks.
* Good performance, no unexplainable slowdowns.
* The Sewers map deserves a mention. It's glorious.

/ The Otherworld seems too confusing for its length.
/ Can't think of anything else.

Probably the best L4D2 campaign I've played the last 6 months. It has everything you could ask for - Large and long maps, no overused respawn closets, beautiful visuals, puzzles, custom audio, survivor dialogue, and ofcourse, the perfectly creepy atmosphere.

Only con I can possibly think of is the Otherworld part. The length combined with the confusing bridges and pathways makes it a bit of a pain to get through. But since it's only one map, it doesn't really change the overall entertainment this campaign brings.

(review may be changed when final update is released)

-Amazing texture
-Real atmosphere of Silent Hill
-Mirror scene
-Sound are perfectly put in game
-Bots are not very buggy
-Story with l4d1 survivors
-DAT FOG!

-Some objects(weapons,pills....) are a bit buggy but we can take them

I play this campaign 15 times and I love it!I hope the next will be Amazing too!

nothing
shit empty streets

boring
very boring map

shit holly shit
maybe atmosphere is good for some players

-nothing

-boring
-very boring
-ultra boring

This is **** map! Never play this ****. It is very boring.

-Great atmosphere; very creepy and nerve-racking. Lots of great effects that add to the tension.
-Well-made environments with no ugly low res textures.
-Excellent choice and placement of original music from the Silent Hill series.
-Good difficulty balance; it is never too hard or too easy (on normal).
-Tons of Silent Hill references and easter eggs!

-At the beginning of Map 1 the characters have awkward stiff animations and the bots will sometimes not follow you if you end up making a wrong turn.
-Maps 2 is prone to crashing at certain points when playing online and SI will spawn behind locked doors. Also, the bots all jumped into a pit at one point, killing themselves and there are a few events that are a little awkward and could use a bit more polish or just be removed outright. This is otherwise the best map in my opinion.
-Map 3 is a little slow and may benefit from more events or more frequent hordes.
-Map 4 is a bit short and not very eventful.

This campaign is coming along beautifully. The environments, sounds, models, and music all make this easily the most immersive and atmospheric campaign I've ever played. I would highly recommend that anyone who is a fan of Silent Hill or horror in general give this a shot, however keep in mind that this is a work in progress and is a little rough around the edges at certain points.

Extremely atmospheric
Beautiful scenery
The fog density and distance is pretty much identical to silent hill
Challenging gameplay
Interesting cut-scenes
Great use of lighting
Good attention to detail
Use of custom skins + models
Use of custom sounds
Lots of Silent Hill nostalgia
Having to look for supplies

Using the flashlight and turning it off caused some graphical error - a gray circle appeared and disappeared(occurred for about a second - but happened many times) - (This only occurred to me - looking into it but have not found a fix yet)

Map 1: AI is quite stupid at the start - they won't enter the first 'saferoom' against tank; sometimes they just open the door and stand there; letting the tank come in.

Map 2: First part focuses on a lot of back tracking - becomes extremely tedious due to the difficulty of this map and the amount of times restarts can occur.
The darkness mixed with the fuzzy/static screen area made the view distance to pretty much a few centi-metres - extremely difficult to navigate in those locations.
Could use one more ammo stack somewhere in the middle - even if it was hidden to be found - I ran out of ammo very easily when the second tier weapons did not spawn.
The cliff! One of us always fell down - kind of a problem on our part - but it was difficult to tell whether or not there was a cliff or not the next meter in front - I think putting a simple arrow on the floor or even a prop (such as a police barrier) near that area can just remind you to not go further - whilst still keeping the danger of there being a cliff. (just a suggestion)
SI would spawn behind locked doors - meaning you would not be attacked by as many SI

Map 3: Way too many supplies - encountered about 20 medkits - felt too easy; quite a bipolar map compared to your others. I think even if you halved the medkit amount the map would still be quite fair to play.

Map 4: The scene with Zoey; although interesting, seemed quite 'buggy' with the animations.
Bots had poor NAV at final tank fight - just hid under the stairs and got beaten.

This campaign is coming out very well and the detail with it is better than any other campaign I have played. The cons were not enough to ruin the experience although were a bit of a disturbance throughout the playthrough. Also, I really enjoy the atmosphere this campaign presents. Also, great to see that you were able to actually make quite an atmospheric campaign within such a limited engine.

-scariest campaign I've played
-captures the feel of Silent Hill
-familiar locations
-custom sounds/models are great (witch ;_; )
-SH soundtrack

-some confusion in 2nd map about where to go/what to do (see below)
-too dark in places
-levels a little long and disjointed

I'm really glad to see that you've picked this campaign back up. I really enjoyed the first Silent Hill campaign, long as it was, and I'm really looking forward to seeing how the final three maps turn out for this campaign. Overall, I really like the direction this campaign is heading. It is probably the scariest campaign I've played (and I've played a lot), so congrats on that. I like all of the custom sounds (i.e. the new witch) as well as the new textures on the specials. I think they really heighten the fear when you're walking down a dark corridor and they just pop out of nowhere. Just that initial shock of "what the ^&$* is that?!?" I've got some things I noticed on my playthrough listed out map by map below. Keep up the great work.

(possible spoilers below)

Map 1:
-Bots do not follow you during the intro if you take the dead end path. This resulted in me trapped in the safe room, tank pounding on the door, and two bots standing around off in the distance.
-There are still some run animation issues in the intro (i.e. bots sliding along in default pose instead of running)

Map 2:
-I love the dark in this level. Really creeps me out. That said, in the outdoor sections, navigation is difficult. Sticking to the wall helped for the first part, but the second part (where you have to cross the road and climb the hill) was very unintuitive. I was following the streetlights on the road... Perhaps add a small light or arrow on the path you're supposed to follow so that it is a bit easier to find.
-In general, it might be a bit *too* dark. Like I said, the darkness creeps me out, but staring at an entire screen full of black for minutes on end eventually goes from creepy to frustrating.
-This map feels a bit too long, especially given all the potential drops to your death in the dark. Might be remedied by slightly improved visibility.

Map 3:
-Nice ambience in the town. I enjoyed exploring and seeing all the signs and stores. Path at the very end was surreal.
-I found a breakable door on one of the buildings toward the end of the level that led out of the map.
-Health packs. Health packs everywhere. I found at least 20 health packs on my way through town. You could cut the number of health packs in half and it would still be too many IMO.

Map 4:
-Breakable door in the first open apartment (upstairs to the left) that lets you see outside the map.
-The animation on the bit with Zoey is a little funky. Funnier than it was scary.
-Couldn't complete this one... There is a part toward the beginning where you drop through a hole in the floor. There are three red-outlined doors down below (one is marked high voltage). I can only open one of the doors. The bots clip through the doorway and then wait, but I cannot get through (i.e. invisible wall). I tried both in single player and local hosted campaign mode. Not sure what to do here.

I hope this helps. I appreciate your hard work on this campaign. Really seems to be paying off. Thanks a bunch.

- Very good storyline
- Creepier than most L4D maps
- Unique sense of set-up
- Very intense
- Captured well on the SH realm

- Players walk in a "Slenderman" pose and will only go into a shoot form when they're not moving
- Too easy to die if your not careful
- Tight spaced in most parts

A good map, but hard to enjoy when the characters were walking around like statues. But did nyone else have this problem?