- It succeeds in being funny to (re)play.
- Naif and unbalanced difficulty peaks that are just challenging
- Every time you play the distribution of the enemies vary a lot, making this campaing deliciously unpredictable

- Sometime the levels would need more attention on the details
- It's really fast to reach the end

There is little to say. This campaign is just funny without being pretentious.

Give it a try, it wont miss give you some fun.

+ A good remake of original HL2 EP1
+ Detailed levels
+ HL music
+ Very nice panic events

- Way too easy if you play with friends, even on expert realism

Its a good campaign to play for anyone - both HL2 fan and a person who is not familiar with HL franchise. Nothing special, just a good campaign! Too easy for group of experienced players though.

-Its HF EP 1
-HF Music
-Supplies and Weapons in good places
-Any HF fun should love it

-3 Witches at the end of 1st map make it difficult to play in expert, expecially with bots
-In 2nd map when you have to desactivate the alarm, normaly theres a tank or a witch and make it really hard to do it

Great map that make you feel like playing half life 2, its really hard to play in expert with bots but is good to play online

• Pretty Accurate to HL2:EP1 Layout
• Interesting Pathway
• Decent Detail and Design
• Pretty Good Weather and Skybox
• Decent Events
• Good Finale

• Wearisome Campaign Throughout [except Finale]
• No Hunting Rifle [4th Playthrough and encountered none]

One of the few good ports of HL2 and the pathing is simple since its almost the same [I think]. I get a little sense of enjoyment but mostly boredom throughout the time, the finale is pretty much the best thing in this campaign [and that plane].

- Half life 2 EP1
- Crowbar in map 2 XD
- Speical infected can get up to the top of the elevator using the vent in map 2
- Scripts
- Music
- Diffrent theme like map 3 was hard rain and map 4 (i think) is dead center

- Alot of witches in the final of map 1
- Blurry textures in the beginning of map 3
- Messed up skybox in map 3

A good map which i think should be a DLC map for left 4 dead 2 But please loosen up the witches a little

======= In general =======
+ HL2 contents.
+ Challenging.
+ Good lighting.
+ Tanks and Witches spread around.
+ Perfect amount of supplies.
+ Unique finale.
+ Detailed maps.
+ Good map structure.
+ Decent AI navigation most of the time.

======= Map 2 =======
- Fell through elevator after Hunter pinned me.
- AI navigation during big horde event might need a fix.
- Big horde event seemed more exaggerated than suiting.
===================

Awesome HL2-based campaign.
No Cons that spoil the gameplay, just maybe the one from map 2, concerning AI NAV. Well done!

The maps are detailed
Awesome custom music (not the heavy rain one)

Map 1 is too dark
Map 1 has 3 witches in a narrow road
Map 2 has 2 horde incident, even though the popular l4d1 campaign has only 1 in each map
Missing texture skybox

I dunno if it is my problem to have missing texture skybox. If anyone has solution, plzzzzz tell me!!
Very awesome custom music that has raise the marks

- Just about a straight port of some of the later sections of HL2. For some, this will be seen as lazy. But, to me, because of the already high quality of those said sections and plus reasons below, it was for the better.

- Has one of those "little bit of everything" vibes to it. There's always a new, effectively used climatic event coming up. Mad props especially to the fire/smoking building section which was far better than what Valve did in any of their own campaigns.

- Decent use of music.

- Lots of little extra nooks to search through.

- I was personally hoping to see a few of the earlier sections featured as those are some of my favorites and would also work great with L4D. Even though the way this is structured makes sense for the sake of further preserving the HL2 design, still.

Overall incredibly solid.

Even though I preferred the fact that it was a straight port of HL2's later parts, it probably could've used a tad more creativity. Or maybe a few extra HL2 characters/sound clips to round out the obvious attempt to be super faithful to game.

What makes this an 8.5, though, is it's variety. It never once got boring.

If you love HL2, I guarantee you will at least really like this campaign.

Good settings.
Good mapping based in Half-Life 2.
Good HL2 atmosphere with HL2 textures and more.

There are some problems with the texture of the sky in two chapters.
The end is really difficult if you play alone and in an high difficult (like all the maps more or less).

Really good campaign based in an excelent game.